| Frank Casatelli | 1989 |
| Stanley F. Gecewicz | 1990 |
| Robert L. Perry | 1991 |
| J. Leo Dugan | 1992 |
| Thomas C. Glenn | 1993 |
| Paul J. Bednarczyk | 1994 |
| Day Response Crew | 1995 |
| Tony Cortese | 1996 |
| Tom Glenn | 1997 |
| 1-15-99 Truck 53 | 1999 |
| Paul J. Laudato | 2000 |
| David P. Clancy | 2001 |
| Anthony G. Cortese | 2002 |
| James White | 2003 |
| Signal 30 Responders | 2004 |
| Shane Deichman Darron Leddick James. D. White | 2004 |
| Robert Leddick | 2006 |
| Stephen J. Haggery | 2007 |
| Benjamin Lockspeiser | 2008 |
| Mark Malone | 2009 |
| Michael Costabile | 2010 |
| Dennis Mason | 2011 |
| Jay Tomisman | 2012 |
| Scott Murray | 2013 |
| Gerry Lugg, Jr. | 2014 |
| Kris Kelly-Sweeney | 2015 |
| Michael Costabile Cameron Becker | 2016 |
| McKFD Charter Members | 2017 |
| David Clancy | 2018 |
| Nolan Renna | 2019 |
| Molly McGuire | 2020 |
| Benjamin Westerman | 2021 |
McKownville Fire
Pride of the East Side
